The choreographer George Balanchine famously compared programming an evening of ballet to planning a menu.  On Saturday, American Ballet Theatre served up an evening of neoclassical fare.

First, a champagne toast with Frederick Ashton’s Birthday Offering.  Conceived in 1956 to celebrate the 25th anniversary of The Sadler’s Wells Ballet, (becoming the Royal Ballet in the same year), this piece d’occasion, in gala style, touted the individual gifts of its ballerinas of the day: (Elaine Fifield, Rowena Jackson, Svetlana Beriosova, Nadia Nerina, Violetta Elvin, Beryl Grey and Margot Fonteyn.) 

Birthday Offering, Royal Ballet

Ashton undoubtedly intended star power to overwhelm the stage.  An ABT buffet of seven stellar couples, primarily principal dancers and soloists, danced in unison in lines, sometimes in alternating, repetitive patterns in cannon. Without a hierarchy among the dancers in the opening waltz, it’s hard to decide where to look next, even after the principal couple take center.  This overwhelm is effective, with one dancer as splendid as the next.  Soon, the cavaliers step aside and look on attentively at each ballerina solo.  The suite of seven female variations forms the centerpiece of the ballet.

Birthday Offering is more dessert than appetizer.  Robert Irving arranged and orchestrated some Glazunov morsels to which Ashton choreographed coquettish, and often fussy steps. Repeated dance phrases, usually in threes, followed by a transition, predictably mirrored the music.  This choreographic formula dominated the whole.  Quirky oddities, humor, and a few poetic endings offered variety.  Each solo had its own flavor, though primarily saccharine.  Hee Seo, the principal ballerina dancing Fonteyn’s role, transcended the occasional awkwardness of the steps with her mature and expansive musical phrasing. 

Next on the menu, an “amuse-bouche” by Kyle Abraham: Mercurial Son.  Contemporary and trendy, Mercurial Son was created for ABT in 2024.  Following in the footsteps of choreographers such as Wayne McGregor and William Forsythe, Abraham layers stylized contemporary movements in the upper body over a foundation of classical ballet vocabulary from the waist down.  Grischa Lichtenberger’s electronic music served as a mood-setting metronome. 

Mercurial Son, ABT

Mercurial Son’s mesmerizing sequences of solos, duets, and trios relate arbitrarily, often in split-screen moments.  The ballet reads as a choreographic stream of consciousness more than cohesive idea. Repeated elements, such as petit allegro jetes, or numerous strings of pique turns, echo throughout, but without providing structure. 

The space of the dancers was lost even further on a fully blackened stage.  Shapes created by lighting designer Dan Scully provided some cohesion of space.  Yet in the stark, flat light, the dancers were scarcely visible. Their feet were overpowered by their own shadows.   Melvin Lawovi’s liberated dancing was most successful at filling the void. 

The main course of the evening, George Balanchine’s Ballet Imperial, a ballet so rich and satisfying, is a complete meal in itself.  Considered the father of both American and Neoclassical Ballet, Balanchine presents dancing with the dazzling grandeur and scale of his beloved Tchaikovsky in the Concerto No. 2 in G for Piano and Orchestra.

Ballet Imperial, Royal Ballet

Both the choreography and music demand devilish virtuosity and amplitude. At the piano, Emily Wong’s flat interpretation sounded muffled from the orchestra pit.  The glorious, young principal, Chloe Misseldine, who danced the soloist role last year, took on the fiendishly difficult ballerina role alongside James Whiteside, now in his retirement year at ABT.  Each at the opposite spectrum of their careers, neither appeared entirely secure: Whiteside with technical demands, and Misseldine with musical and artistic nuance.  The newly appointed soloist Yoon Jung Seo, a brilliant young technician, delivered a clean but rigid performance. 

The corps de ballet also missed some of the detail required to present this masterpiece at its apex: fleet, crisp footwork, incisive musicality, a supple upper body and generous port de bras, and general amplitude and risky abandon throughout.  Danced regularly at the New York City Ballet, Balanchine’s home company, obviously more fluent in the Balanchine style, this same ballet, entitled Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 2 at NYCB, has slowly drifted towards sloppiness and even an exaggerated vulgarity.  For varying reasons, and to differing degrees, each company falls short of what this ballet can deliver.

Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 2, NYCB

Over the years, the costumes and sets have changed numerous times.  At the New York City Ballet, “PC2” is presented in flowing dresses rather than tutus worn at ABT.   ABT’s latest costume and set designs by Jean-Marc Puissant combine awkwardly-fitted, printed blue bodices, seemingly alien to the gold-trimmed tutus to which they are attached.  Similarly mismatched, the sets, consisting of abstracted columns and chandelier fixtures, lack harmony in color and style.

American Ballet Theatre’s smorgasbord of talent leaves audiences hungry for more.  Among the many excellent dancers appearing on Saturday evening’s program, a few of the noteworthy include the young corps de ballet dancer, Elisabeth Beyer, the newly promoted principal Jake Roxander, (although somewhat ill-at-ease in Saturday’s Mercurial Son), and the outstanding soloist Takumi Miyake, who both electrify audiences with their pyrotechnic technique, without abandoning good taste, and, finally, the newly appointed principal Jarod Curley, whose refined elegance is increasingly rare onstage nowadays.

Behind the Ballet with Elizabeth Kaye, ABT